PwC forensic audit and governance reviews cited to show the widely reported “$20 billion fraud” allegation was not established against the former Nigerian oil minister, who was a policy maker and reformer without any operational control whatsoever over NNPC accounts
Campaigners have challenged the way former Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor Sanusi Lamido Sanusi’s public allegations of “$20 billion missing oil money” have been portrayed in international and local media as alleged fraud by former Petroleum Minister Diezani Alison‑Madueke, a prominent Christian.
They note that the subsequent PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) forensic audit into Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) remittances did not find that Diezani Alison‑Madueke personally diverted $20 billion whatsoever, and calls for a clear correction of record.
The statement recalls that Sanusi, an Islamic scholar who served as CBN Governor from 2009 to 2014, publicly alleged that up to $20 billion in oil revenues were unaccounted for between 2012 and 2013, and directly linked this controversy to the then oil minister in his international media interventions.
He was suspended in February 2014 by President Goodluck Jonathan for issues related to his CBN tenure and basically framed Alison‑Madueke globally as the face of the alleged missing billions, even though she was strictly a policy maker and reformer without direct operational control over NNPC trading and cash transfers.
According to the statement, the PwC investigative audit – commissioned by the Federal Government and released via the Auditor‑General confirmed serious weaknesses, discrepancies and infractions within NNPC’s accounting and remittance systems, but it most certainly did not uphold the headline claim of any cash, not to mention the outrageous claim of $20 billion cash theft attributable to Alison‑Madueke.
A comprehensive parliamentary hearing on this matter by the Nigerian senate concluded that $18.5 bn had judiciously been cut in subsidy payments whilst $1.5 bn had been misappropriated by the NNPC – paid or remitted to wrong categories within the organisation.
Instead, PwC identified a much lower recommended refund to the Federation Account and highlighted systemic governance failures, data unreliability and conflicting figures across agencies, destroying the baseless, damaging, headline grabbing narrative that Alison-Madueke had in any way “stolen $20 billion”.
The statement stresses that Alison‑Madueke’s role as Minister of Petroleum Resources was primarily to set policy, lead sector reform and oversee institutions, not to operate NNPC accounts or execute physical transfers of crude proceeds.
As such, the claim that she herself “took” or “transferred” $20 billion grossly mischaracterises both her formal remit and the findings of the PwC exercise, which focused on institutional remittance gaps rather than any judicial finding of personal misappropriation by the minister in relation to Sanusi’s specific allegation.
The statement further notes that Sanusi has since been reinstated on May 23, 2024 as Co-Emir of Kano, a powerful traditional and moral Islamic authority position, making it even more important for the historical record to distinguish between contested allegations and proven facts in relation to his tenure‑era accusations.
Media references now frequently describe him as Emir while also recycling old coverage that presents the “$20 billion fraud” as settled truth about Alison‑Madueke.
Key points from the statement
-
Sanusi’s $20 billion claim was an allegation of unremitted oil revenue, not a court finding that Diezani Alison‑Madueke personally stole that sum.
-
The PwC forensic audit revealed serious NNPC governance failures, but did not confirm that $20 billion in cash was missing in the way originally framed, nor that the former minister had the operational capacity to move such funds.
-
Diezani Alison‑Madueke’s position was that of a policy maker and reformer, not an NNPC finance operator, and she was not in a position to initiate or execute the transfer of crude proceeds from NNPC accounts.
-
Sensational, personalised framing in international media has inflicted long‑term reputational harm by presenting a disputed, unreconciled figure as proven fraud tied to one named individual.
Quotes
“Accountability debates in Nigeria’s oil sector must be anchored in what audits actually say, not what headlines suggest,” say Campaigners. “The PwC review highlighted structural and accounting problems at NNPC, but it did not validate the story that Diezani Alison‑Madueke personally stole $20 billion, nor could it, given her non‑operational role.”
“Diezani was a policy‑maker, not a cashier,” added the Campaigners. “Sanusi’s public accusations turned a complex institutional remittance issue into a personalised global scandal, and the record now needs to reflect that the audit evidence does not support the idea that she had the authority or capacity to transfer billions out of NNPC accounts as alleged.”
